Lesson 151C1

Un dîner qui tourne au débat — A Dinner That Turns into a Debate

Troisième année · Third Year

This lesson needs a pass

Lessons 1–10 of every course are free and open — no account, no payment.

See passes

0 of 9 done

Hover a line for its translation; hover a word for its meaning. Tap 🔊 to hear it.

Julien
Je maintiens ce que je disais à l'apéro : quand un étranger fait une faute en français, lui rendre service, c'est le corriger, gentiment mais tout de suite. Quand j'étais serveur, je corrigeais tous les touristes qui disaient « une café », et personne ne s'en est jamais plaint, que je sache. Alex, tu en es la preuve vivante : je t'ai corrigé dès ton premier café, et regarde le résultat.
I stand by what I said over drinks: when a foreigner makes a mistake in French, doing them a favor means correcting them, kindly but right away. When I was a waiter, I corrected every tourist who said "une café", and nobody ever complained, as far as I know. Alex, you're the living proof: I corrected you from your very first coffee, and look at the result.
Sophie
Laisse-moi finir avant de crier victoire, parce que tu oublies un détail : personne ne t'avait demandé de corriger qui que ce soit, que je sache. Corriger quelqu'un qui ne te l'a pas demandé, c'est le traiter en élève, et c'est exactement ce qui provoque l'insécurité dont Alex parle dans son mémoire. Et puis, tes touristes ne se plaignaient pas, mais à ce que je sache, ils ne revenaient pas non plus.
Let me finish before you claim victory, because you're forgetting one detail: nobody had asked you to correct anyone, as far as I know. Correcting someone who hasn't asked you to is treating them like a pupil, and that's exactly what causes the insecurity Alex talks about in his thesis. And besides, your tourists didn't complain, but as far as I know, they didn't come back either.